What makes corporate restructuring projects so difficult?

Meeting fra manager che definiscono una strategia.

In today’s relentlessly shifting market, agility and continuous evolution are no longer optional for businesses; they are imperatives, frequently driven by transformative projects. The cost of inaction is steep: erosion of competitive edge, and in extreme cases, outright failure.

Alarmingly, statistics reveal that the majority of these crucial transformation efforts fall short. Tony Saldanha, drawing from research by McKinsey and PwC, highlights that a staggering 70% of such initiatives fail to deliver, even with substantial financial backing.

Why do so many transformation initiatives falter?

While numerous factors contribute to their failure, two stand out

1. Strategic Alignment: The Cornerstone of Successful Transformation

Strategic alignment involves harmonizing business strategies with the necessary resources, processes, and skills. It ensures operational activities align with strategic plans, driving long-term success through a shared understanding of purpose.

In “Why Digital Transformations Fail,” Tony Saldanha identifies five essential pillars for successful digital transformation:

  • Clear Strategy: A well-defined vision and robust strategy are paramount. For further insight, consider “Made to Stick” by the Heath brothers.
  • Stakeholder Engagement: Active participation from all stakeholders, including employees and customers, is critical. Delaying engagement creates a culture of passive commentary rather than proactive contribution.
  • Methodical Execution: Disciplined execution prevents resource waste. Incremental daily improvements (1%) outweigh attempts at immediate, drastic change.
  • Internal Skill Development: Investing in skills, particularly by aligning with individual motivations, accelerates transformation significantly compared to purely top-down approaches.
  • Continuous Monitoring and Adaptation: Transformation is an ongoing process requiring constant evaluation and adjustments.

In my 15 years of experience as a strategic consultant, I’ve witnessed firsthand transformation projects fail due to a lack of alignment (point 2) and skill development (point 4).

A lack of synergy between the change strategy and its translation of ‘meaning’ at all levels of the organization creates brakes, sometimes invisible, that slow down or stop the transformation.
In other words, if you fail to bridge the gap between the ‘why‘ of the transformation and the ‘how‘ people need to act and grow to achieve it, the risk of failure doubles.

2. Develop Soft Skills, not just Hard Skills, consistent with the challenges of transformation.

Recent MIT research highlights that investing in the development of soft skills leads to significant returns on investment.
So, how do you build skills for a successful transformation?

  • Balance technological investments with management skill development: Always accompany the implementation of new technologies with a review of their interaction flows with all impacted personnel, not just those directly affected. The development of broad management skills is often underestimated.
  • Develop soft skills in more technical professionals: Enhance the communication, empathy, and collaboration skills of more technical teams to facilitate integration and change management within the organization at all levels, not only in those roles where soft skills are more prominent.
  • Promote continuous learning: Adopt a culture of continuous learning, encouraging employees to expand their skills and stay updated on new technologies. Learning and Development (L&D) professionals play a key role in fostering an environment where employees actively seek opportunities to broaden their skills; often, budgets for these activities are perceived as costs.
  • Training and upskilling for everyone: Offer targeted training programs and coaching activities to impart the essential knowledge and skills needed to operate before, during, and after transformation, not only towards populations that are trained recurrently, such as talents, managers, etc.
  • Foster an innovative organizational culture: Adopt an organizational culture open to change and curious about new developments, through programs chosen by employees themselves.
  • Transparent and widespread communication: Support transparent and widespread communication within the company.
  • Employee listening and engagement: Overcome resistance to change through a participatory approach that involves employees, including in the identification and implementation of solutions.

Conclusion

Transformations often fail due to the failure to achieve strategic alignment across all personnel, at their respective operational levels, with adequate skills, and through clear communication of purpose.

A disconnect between the change strategy and its effective transmission of ‘meaning’ at all organizational levels can create impediments that impede or halt transformation.

Dayana Mejias Roman 's article

I assist organizations in resolving conflicts among individuals, teams, and departments. I focus on finding solutions to mitigate friction arising from innovation and change, particularly when new competencies are required. I am driven by a deep understanding of human dynamics and the fostering of harmonious collaboration amidst diverse perspectives.

Sign up and unlook you potential !

Start your learning journey with your digital mentor! Viblio is the ideal tool for your personal professional growth or to manage the training of your team or company.

✔️ 14 days free trial
✔️ No credit card required
Did you like our article?

Share it with people who might be interested in